Money Grubbing in Educational Publishing. Nothing New Here Folks, Move Along.


The happy curmudgeon, Jim West, commented on the rather shocking price of a recent book. $590.00 list price from Brill for a 2000 page for a new etymological Greek dictionary from Brill (who else?). My own tome from last year is around $100.00 (from Ashgate), so its price per page is even higher but since it doesn’t have have a picture of me in it it is probably worth it.

But here is a deal. My friend Tom Robinson (whose own recent book of Ignatius of Antioch goes for a rather modest sum from Hendrickson) is also the author of a self published little volume that was something of hobby project for the past few years with a small entry on a related issue.

Ignatius of Antioch and the Parting of the Ways:
Early Jewish-Christian Relations

IggyTom’s new baby. Click Here.


Anyway, I don’t have a cover shot of Tom’s new new book (compiled and edited with Sharon (Mrs. Tom), but it is called

EVERYTHING OLD IS NEWS AGAIN

While working on a different project that required snooping through hundreds and thousands of pages of old newspapers, Tom noticed how often newspapers a hundred years ago and so reported on issues that are strikingly up to date. Here is one (p. 79) from THE DAILY GAZETTE AND BULLETIN from Jan. 27, 1877

New Editions of Textbooks Too Frequent.

Mr. Mitchell has introduced a bill into the legislature to prevent changes in school books more than once in six years. No measure of relief will be hailed with more satisfaction than a law of this kind, so that the constant changing of school books has become one of the most annoying evils that a patient people have to endure without any benefit except to gratify the whims of teachers and put money in the pockets of rival publishers.

Here is another one (p. 78) from a little later.

Fads in Education

Our public schools stand in danger of being invaded by another fad. they have suffered from various fads in the past and will likely do so again in the future. It seems one of the weaknesses inherent in human nature to adopt readily whatever is new or novel or catchy, no matter whether it is reasonable or not. Educational work is unfortunately not free from this weakness. Some educationalist after much philosophizing and theorizing evolves some new or novel scheme, some publisher gets a hold of it and by judicious and liberal use of printer’s ink proclaims it to the world as a new system bound to revolutionize educational method.
The Centralia Enterprise and Tribute (July 28, 1894:7)

The more things change, the more things stay the same! And here are the same ideas, in the interpretative medium of lolcat!

Why must you get the 17th edition of my text-book?
moar funny pictures

9 Responses to “Money Grubbing in Educational Publishing. Nothing New Here Folks, Move Along.”

  1. Jim Says:

    your kitty has captured the true facts.

  2. Dr. Jim Says:

    Pearson Education has taught him well!

  3. Stacy Says:

    $590! And I was whining because I had to pay $110 for my 2nd edition Arky text.

    This is why U of L students LOVE course packs. (we tend to hold the Profs that use them in high esteem as well hint hint) LOL

  4. Al Says:

    OK, here is the teacher’s side of the text book ‘debate’. Teachers love textbooks, good students actually use the darn things. Which textbook is in use in Grades 1 to 12 is controlled by Big Government®. What happens in post-secondary is completely out our hands and in the realm for the ivory-tower dudes. In my subject area, Physics and general science, there is only 1 authorized text for each subject. The schools have 2 choices: take it or leave it. Then there is the regulation that requires that students have access to the textbook for each subject. Let’s NOT talk about Pearson.

  5. andrewbourne Says:

    Is this a first in Biblioblog History Jim West being nice about a cat. Is Jim well or is some avatar of Jim being nice to cats. I think that he sees a psychiatrist soon or you never own he might to decide to own a cat himself

  6. UNRR Says:

    This post has been linked for the HOT5 Daily 11/19/2009, at The Unreligious Right

  7. Steve Wiggins Says:

    You left out a category even further to the right on your chart. Gorgias Press books should stand in a class of their own. If you look at the per-page cost, you might find even Brill looking reasonable!

  8. 1minionsopinion Says:

    I recall a Rural Sociology course at the uni of Regina where the guy made us buy 5 different books, referred to only one of them for the whole semester, and then threw questions from the other four at us for our final. Like anyone had actually bothered to read those…I seem to recall a lot of B.S. involved in getting my B.A.

  9. The Textbook Industry Makes Me Sick | A Fistful of Farthings Says:

    [...] and an added paragraph should not constitute a new edition with an updated (jacked-up) price. Jim Linville had it right back in [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>